South African Cultural Observatory

Beyond the creative economy?

BY 31.10.17

IT IS conference planning season for the South African Cultural Observatory (SACO). This means an intense review of the trends and research emerging from the creative and cultural industries (CCIs) and the arts, culture and heritage (ACH) sectors. I spent three weeks recently travelling to Europe and the United Kingdom, which gave me some real first hand insight to some of the most pressing issues on the minds of many thinkers, academics, researchers, economists and policy-makers. There is much to be excited about. There is also much to be worried about.

As we plan the SACO’s third national conference, we have embraced the theme, ‘Beyond the creative economy? Trends and Issues in National and Regional Economies’. This means that we are considering a future trajectory for thinking about creativity and its role in our society. In1992, James Carville, a strategist to Bill Clinton, coined the powerful phrase, “It's the economy, stupid”. It still is, but what that economy means and who it serves has changed radically in the past 25 years.

We are more interconnected, intertwined, inter-reliant than ever before. Yet social and economic division mar efforts to establish real collaboration and effect real change. It may be the economy, but it’s all the other things too. There has, arguably, never been such a pressing time for creative solutions – and thus the thinking that takes us beyond the creative economy and into new spaces where creativity can be in the service of solution.

There are some serious shortcomings of current prescriptions around the creative economy. These include its neo-liberal character, declining public spending on arts and culture, and the shortcomings of relying on the creative class for social reform, among other challenges.

We are working on developing a call for papers for the conference that explores these and other issues as an important route to delving into ‘The Problem with the Creative Economy’. This is one of the most critical discussions we can have right now.

A conversation problematizing the creative economy also adds value to other debates, such as how we map out the creative economy – and really describe its nuances and dimensions. In addition, as the new White Paper on Arts, Culture and Heritage is being recrafted, it is important to consider the real problems with base conceptualisation – and then of course operationalisation – of the creative economy and indeed policy in regard to arts, culture and heritage in South Africa.

As already indicated in the recent mid-term budget, and given the current development trajectory, there will be probably not, in real terms, be much increasing state support for the ACH sectors. Rather there is likely to be a gap between what is proposed and what is implemented.  However, the discourse and debate assumes increased and widespread state support.

During my European visit, I found during a definite decrease in state overall support for spending in the ACH sectors. So in a sense the creative economy – especially one that is organic, and market-orientated – is a policy response to this process or trend. We also need to consider how economies/savings are to be made in an environment of enforced frugality. This does not necessarily entail a purely neo-liberal solution, but would require a more thoroughgoing invocation of non-state actors, especially the third sector. 

So how do we achieve smart state intervention or growth on a (limited) budget? When rent-seeking is added to the mix how do we conceptualize and research the creative economy most especially in developing and transitional economies? These are questions we will ask at the #SACOConf2018. We need your voice in this – so please start thinking of how you can add to these debates and discussions and join us for the conference.

Update on SACO Activities

The SACO Domain Workshop series drew to a close in October and again was a fundamentally critical process of engagement and learning for both us and for the practitioners. Unathi Lutshaba, our Research Manager, has worked on an interesting summary of the concerns raised and insights gained. This will contribute to the development of our conference call for papers and also a report on the domain workshops.

Our research process is also well underway. We are working on five main reports which overall will contribute to the mega mapping study commissioned. 

  1. Cultural and Creative Industry Employment Report (using LSF data)
  2. International Trade & Cultural Goods
  3. Shifting Ownership and Transformation
  4. Provinces, location and clusters
  5. Macro-economic Report

The research will be published in the coming months, so watch this space.

 Until then, enjoy the October edition of The Cultural Observer.

 Your Culturalist,

Prof. Richard Haines

South African Cultural Observatory: CEO

New knowledge is power - A final word New knowledge is power - A final word

LOUIS L'Amour said, 'There will come a time when you believe everything is finished. Yet that will be the beginning.' In many respects, this is the end of something and the birth of something new. Nelson Mandela University - and its partners, the Universities of Rhodes and Fort Hare - are concluding the three-year South African Cultural Observatory contract with the Department of Arts & Culture.

#SACOConf2018 programme cross-section of research, sector snapshots #SACOConf2018 programme cross-section of research, sector snapshots

THE South African Cultural Observatory 2018 International Conference programme represents a cross-section of global and local research and sector status snapshots. We are very excited to be hosting our third international conference at the Nelson Mandela Bay Stadium in Port Elizabeth next week on 7 and 8 March.


SA Cultural Observatory – By the Numbers SA Cultural Observatory – By the Numbers

IT IS an exciting time for the South African Cultural Observatory led by a consortium headed by Nelson Mandela University. We are wrapping on what has been a three-year-long contract with the Department of Arts and Culture and we are preparing to bid to host the SACO again.

#SACOCOnf2018: Going beyond #SACOCOnf2018: Going beyond

WELCOME to the conference edition of the newsletter. This month we moved swifly to launch the SACO's 2018 Conference website, announce the conference theme, issue out a call for papers, and open registration. We have a very exciting international conference coming up that is both forward and backward looking as we seek of view 'Beyond the Creative Economy: Trends and Issues in National and Regional Economies’.


More News
Business and Arts South Africa appoints incoming CEO Business and Arts South Africa appoints incoming CEO

BASA has appointed current executive producer for the National Arts Festival (NAF), Ashraf Johaardien as the new chief executive of the organisation.

Minister Mthethwa Interaction with the Creative Industries Minister Mthethwa Interaction with the Creative Industries

The creative and cultural economies are one of the fastest growing industries and should be at the centre of national strategic priority to unlock the wider socio- economic participation and inclusivity in the mainstream economy. The impact of commodity-dependent countries like South Africa has refocused attention on the urgency of economic diversification, revitalization and harnessing of human innovation in order to weather the economic storm.

Music in Africa Foundation honors Eric Wainaina Music in Africa Foundation honors Eric Wainaina

Kenyan musician Eric Wainaina was feted with the 2018 Music In Africa Honorary Award at the opening of the Music In Africa Conference for Collaborations, Exchange and Showcases (ACCES) on Thursday night.

Research is the word: What's done, what's to come Research is the word: What's done, what's to come

THE SOUTH African Cultural Observatory has a trove of research. Over the past three years we have generated research reports, monitoring and evaluation reports, a ground-breaking mapping study and more. We are intent on sharing this research widely and ensuring that the sector benefits, empowering through knowledge.

New administrator joins SACO team New administrator joins SACO team

THE South African Cultural Observatory welcomes Rene Derrocks to the team as the incoming new administrator. Rene has eight years’ experience in the tourism marketing environment.

Connect with us