thumbnail-92-commissionedresearchcreativecitiesinmetropolitanareas.webp

The intention is to undertake a broader assessment and outline an indicator framework sensitive to the South African context to assess the existence and level of success of ‘creative cities’.

Overview

There is increasing interest in the concept of creative cities, with the number of cities embracing the notion of being a creative city growing as well. The creative city concept aligns directly with urban development strategies and local economic development planning, intended to improve growth through cultural and creative activities. The international prominence of creative cities is evident in the United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organisation’s (UNESCO) Creative Cities Network and Programmes, with more than 240 member cities located in 72 countries. South Africa has three UNESCO recognised creative cities: Cape Town (design), Overstrand (gastronomy) and Durban (literature). Creative cities go beyond cultural and creative industry aspects and include broader issues pertaining to innovations and seeking creative solutions to urban challenges, which occur at three levels: upperground, underground and middleground. In South Africa, there is limited but extremely useful research that focuses on creative cities that this study draws on. In this context, this study critically examines current scholarly literature on creative cities generally and in South Africa specifically, focusing on opportunities and challenges and socio-economic benefits associated with creative cities. A desktop study approach is adopted that examines policy documents, research reports and academic sources.

The creative city concept itself is contested and multidimensional, with different manifestations and reasons for adopting this approach. Creative cities have also evolved from focusing on cultural and creative activities as a public good to the centrality of economic and developmental justifications. Thus, creative cities tend to have two orientations: cultural and economic. However, key characteristics/ attributes associated with creative cities relate to transforming urban spaces and creative placemaking, links with the creative economy, focus on social and cultural infrastructure, a critical mass of creative contributors and employees, opportunities to participate in cultural experiences, and investments in cultural resources and activities. Additionally, creative cities are characterised by creative clusters, precincts and genres. Three creative clusters are evident, which include independent creators, crafters and creative producers, and specialised service supply providers.

Benefits associated with the agglomeration of cultural production and creative activities are also underscored. Creative cities are also aligned to broader aspirations of creating
sustainable, inclusive and resilient cities. Additionally, focusing on innovation and integrating technology and culture is increasing in prominence. Furthermore, creative cities often transition from industrial cities and/ or embrace creativity to address socio-economic challenges as evident in many of UNESCO’s recognised creative cities. The main public investments in creative cities are infrastructure, provision of land and space for cultural and creative purposes, and financial incentives. Key challenges associated with creative cities are the levels of participation of different groups, bias in terms of types of cultural genres/ forms supported, creating conducive environments, infrastructural limitations, policy and institutional support, funding and resource allocation, social inequalities and conflict, and undermining the intrinsic value of creativity. The Coronavirus 2019 (COVID-19) pandemic reinforced challenges as well as reveals new opportunities and responses within creative cities.

In the South African context, nurturing creative cities is linked to aspirations to unlock the potential of the creative and cultural industries (CCIs). Concern is raised that models and approaches of the North tend to dominant creative cities in the South, which raise concerns. In South Africa, creative cities appear to either be linked to creative precincts (that is, spatial locations designated for creative activities) or creative thematic foci (that is, creative genres or activities that cities are known for). The three UNESCO recognised creative cities (Cape Town, Durban and Overstrand) focus on the UNESCO identified genres but also have projects and programmes that embrace other forms of creativity. Other creative cities identified as illustrative examples in South Africa include Johannesburg, Pretoria, Grahamstown and Phakamisa/ King Williams Town. It is evident that different sizes and types of cities/ towns are embracing the concept of creative cities in South Africa. Of concern is that none had creative city-specific policies in the three main UNESCO listed creative cities, and there was limited reference to creative cities in the Integrated Development Plans. Implementation challenges in South Africa are also identified, including policy development and alignment, raising awareness about creative cities, understanding and responding to inequalities, and accessing funding and reliable information. These challenges are not unique to South African. A 'creative cities culture' exists in South Africa, and its evolution and foci align to international trends.

The main recommendations emanating from this study is the importance of creative stakeholders being at the centre of decision-making processes. In the wake of the COVID-19 pandemic, technological advancements and integration need to be considered. Understanding the unique strengths and creative attributes in specific cities are important for branding and marketing. The main contribution of this study is the development of a framework to measure and monitor the performance of creative cities in South Africa, drawing on Yum’s (2020) creativity index (3Ci - creative class, creative infrastructure and culture), which is an extension of the 3Ts (Talent, Technology and Tolerance) index, and the multidimensional index proposed by Rodrigues and Franco (2018). The indicator framework is important to inform an audit or baseline information to be collected for the three UNESCO recognised creative cities in South Africa as well as assist other cities/ towns as well as the Department of Sports, Arts and Culture (DSAC) to assess the potential to be positioned as a creative city. Finally, research recommendations are also forwarded in relation to examining cultural workers in creative cities and the application of the proposed monitoring framework.

Join Our Mailing List
Sign Up Now